@privacy How to be private with google services and noroot.
I can’t disable google play services for a lot of reasons (school apps, UPI, etc). I have three main google apps enabled. Gservices, gmail+meet, gpay. I have replaced as much apps as possible. Any guide for being private for me?
Island work without root. It is based on a “work profile” feature of android devvices. It is not a complete privacy, but at least it allows to separate google apps from other apps.
I wonder how good it is compared to shelter
It is an interesting question… It seems to me I compared it and I chose Island. But I cannot remember why :D
UPD. I chose Island/Insular only because it is updated more frequently:
- The latest release of Insular was at May 20, 2024 and frequency is ~ a release per two months
- The latest release of Shelter (on F-Droid) was at Dec 12, 2023 and frequency is ~ a release per year
Take a look at this:
https://www.privacyguides.org/en/android/general-apps/
Shelter is recommended over Insular and Island as it supports contact search blocking.
When using Shelter, you are placing complete trust in its developer, as Shelter acts as a Device Admin to create the Work Profile, and it has extensive access to the data stored within the Work Profile.
I also remember starting with island but changing to shelter because it supports app pausing without using a third party proprietary app to pause work apps
Can’t gapps act as root on all profiles? I don’t think this buys you anything as long as gapps is installed.
deleted by creator
Removed by mod
It’s probably Google sharing that information with Amazon. Amazon isn’t actively spying on Google searches. I could be wrong though, but that is what Google “Ad Privacy” spyware is really about. To let Google share your interests with other companies.
I just ran a test on my stock Pixel 8 Pro connected via Proton VPN:
-
I opened Firefox and searched DuckDuckGo for “pool heater”.
-
I scrolled down until I saw an Amazon link, then closed the tab and Firefox.
-
I opened the Amazon app. I scrolled through the “deals” on the app’s home page and did not see anything pool related at all.
-
I typed “pool” into the search slowly, to see if and when “pool heater” was suggested as a search. I typed in “pool” entirely, yet “pool heater” was never suggested.
I don’t know what that implies, but it seems like if I am using Firefox, DDG, and Proton VPN, Amazon isn’t monitoring my Internet searches.
Removed by mod
-
How to swim without getting wet without a websuit?
You might be able to get a large part of google functionality with a degoogled device running microG or something similar.
deleted by creator
Get secondary device for private privacy stuff.
deleted by creator